📖About

The step reviewer checks whether completed steps have met their success criteria. It provides pass or fail verdicts that guide step progression.

Its role is limited to reviewing steps. It does not modify plans, dispatch work or escalate issues.

📖Usage

The reviewer is used on demand when a completed step needs checking against its success criteria. It supports the estate’s work by assessing the evidence for completion.

📖Purpose

sr-s1 validates that each completed step met its success criteria, providing pass/fail verdicts that drive step progression.

📖Duties

- Load step success_criteria from initiative_plans
- Evaluate criteria against task evidence via Claude
- Write review_verdict (pass/fail)
- On fail: increment run_number, optionally invoke diagnostics
- Idempotent: skips if verdict already written

📖Constraints

Only reviews steps; does not modify plans, dispatch work, or escalate.

👤Belongs to

• Merlin